Weeks ago, I wrote about my experience in visiting famed author of the Little House books Laura Ingalls Wilder’s house in Mansfield, Missouri. I had read her newly released autobiography before taking this trip, and all of this information made me want to read her daughter’s writing.
Rose Wilder Lane was an established and successful author before her mother published any of the Little House books. In fact, she encouraged her mother to write down her life story, and some believe Rose was instrumental in writing and revising some of the Little House books. Her vision helped make them what they became. In fact, the museum in Mansfield contained many of Roses’s things as well , including her writing desk.
And yet, I’ve never read anything by Rose Wilder Lane, and I didn’t even know she existed until learning more about Laura Ingalls Wilder, whom I have known and loved since childhood. So I picked up Let the Hurricane Roar (1933) by Rose Wilder Lane to give her a chance.
I was shocked and delighted at this book! It begins by introducing a young married couple, named Charles and Caroline (the names of Laura’s parents), who begin a journey West to claim a homestead. I realized immediately that this was Rose’s version of the Little House story. In fact, many of the major episodes of this book appear under different circumstances in the Little House books, but this book is a fictional account of Charles and Caroline’s experiences, for they start out West with no children, and when their first baby is born, it is a boy. I suspect that Rose was inspired by the stories her mother told her and used those to create a fictional account of the settling of the American West.
The familiar episodes include Charles and Caroline living “by the banks of Plum Creek” in a dugout, Charles returning in a blizzard all covered in snow and surprising Caroline, the appearance of millions of grasshoppers to eat their wheat crop, and the discovery of a herd of cattle with ice on their eyes in a blizzard. New to the story is that Charles leaves Caroline for an entire winter alone in that dugout, because he breaks his leg while working out East, and she must survive on her own. In the Little House books, I believe that when Charles must leave the family, Caroline always has Mary and Laura and Carrie to help her.
In this depiction of pioneers, I saw Rose’s attempts to create a mythology of the American West, a common aim of authors, such as Willa Cather, in the early twentieth century. Rose seems to have been romanticizing that time, while presenting its hardships and difficulties realistically. She describes the Lone Tree that Charles and Caroline pass on their way to the homestead as “a solitary cottonwood, a landmark for all that country, and Charles drove out of his way to get some seeds from it” (p. 13). That tree and its symbolism comes back into play several times through the narrative, and it reminded me of Willa Cather’s symbol of the American West in My Antonia, that of the sun going down behind the plough left in the field. From a literary perspective, Cather created a symbol of the West more skillfully than did Lane.
Throughout, the writing is simplistic and accessible. My library labeled the copy I read as a Young Adult novel, so perhaps she was writing the mythic novel of the American West for a younger audience, in the style of her mother’s work. I enjoyed it nevertheless, and I still see it as worthy of a read.
To bring the myth full circle, Caroline declares in a letter to Charles that “We are having hard times now, but we should not dwell upon them but think of the future. It has never been easy to build up a country, but how much easier it is for us . . . than it was for our forefathers. I trust that, like our own parents, we may live to see times more prosperous than they have ever been in the past, and we will then reflect with satisfaction that these hard times were not in vain” (p. 121-122). These words immortalize the work of many generations of pioneers, and show the hope and faith that such men and women must have had to keep going and to settle a country that was wild and unkind. The line “let the hurricane roar” comes from Charles’s favorite hymn, which he fittingly plays on the fiddle, a prominent feature of the Little House books, when he returns.
If you are interested in a new and continued perspective on the Little House stories, this is the book for you. I’m glad I picked it up, for I discovered more about Caroline and Charles Ingalls, although fictional, than I knew existed. This book humanizes and personifies these two mighty people more than Laura did in her books, as she focused on them from a child’s perspective. Lane wrote them as the protagonists of the great American novel.
That’s so interesting!
It was fun to “discover” her work!
I love Charles and Caroline. I don’t think there is such a thing as too much of them. Added to my list- thanks! I’m glad you decided to try it.
BTW, I love the book cover, too!
Absolutely! They were fascinating people and I would love to read more and more and more about them.
That is absolutely fascinating. I never knew Rose wrote anything, but this sounds like it would be well worth reading!
Yes, worth the read. I want to read more of her writings now.
I’m sure I would enjoy this book!
Let me know if you do!
Neat find. I also never knew about Rose Wilder Lane. I’m definitely adding it to my list.
I think much of her work was journalistic, so I’ll have to look into that side of her writing. In fact, Laura did that sort of writing as well before publishing her novels.
“Let the Hurricane Roar” (or “Young Pioneers” as it was called when I read it) is one of my favorites and I love it so much more than the Willa Cather books I’ve tried… though I was young when I read both authors… I will definitely have to give both a new look with my adult eyes! Thank you for the reminder 🙂
I think this one would be worth it to reread as an adult, and if you haven’t found a love for Cather yet, please try her again. She’s amazing, but I can totally see how this would be better for a young reader when it comes to pioneers and the West.
I just picked up “O, Pioneers!” I think I may have read this one, once upon a time, but can’t really remember. Guess I’ll find out when I start reading it! Thanks for the recommendation.
I hope you like it!
Emily, what a nice discovery. I will look for it. I have been scoping out Father’s Day books for my kids to give me . I have hinted at “The Road to Character” by David Brooks and “Factory Man” about a family member and CEO of Bassett Furniture kept his company in America and remained profitable through worker loyalty and engagement. I might suggest this one to round it out. Thanks, BTG
Interesting books for Father’s Day. I may have to steal your suggestions and give them to my dad!
Reblogged this on kaytechworld.
Reblogged this on kaytechworld.
Fascinating. I love Willa Cather so will have to try and check her books. Thanks!
I think you’ll like this one, then! Enjoy.
Thanks for letting us all know about Rose Wilder Lane. Her mother is much more well-known, but it sounds like Rose’s writing deserves to be read as well. I am definitely interested in a different perspective on the Little House books.
I’ve never read Willa Cather — which book of hers would you recommend starting with?
P.S. I like the new look of your blog! I keep thinking that mine is due for a makeover but I like my theme too much to change it! 🙂
Thanks! I had a hard time changing, but I like what I ended up choosing. Willa Cather is all good. Start with My Antonia, and then try O Pioneers. 🙂
I’ll add them to my TBR list. 🙂
Thoroughly enjoyed the write-up!