Social Class as a False Marker of Virtue: A Girl of the Limberlost

It turns out that A Girl of the Limberlost (1909) by Gene Stratton-Porter is a sequel to another book, called Freckles. I realized this as I marked A Girl of the Limberlost as “read” on Goodreads, and saw that it was labeled #2. And then I realized that a character in the book, Freckles, whom I had no context for and couldn’t figure out where he fit into the rest of the plot, was the title character of the first book.


Limberlost is about Elnora Comstock, a young girl who lives in the woods with her angry and depressed mother. Elnora wants to attend high school, and studies hard to get there, but her mother is unkind and seems to want to see her fail. Elnora gets into high school anyway, and finds herself ridiculed and standing out like a sore thumb. She’s out of fashion and doesn’t know where to buy her books.

The next few sections of the book focus on Elnora’s “makeover” and her ability to become like the other children. Her Aunt Margaret and Uncle Wesley help, and eventually her mother comes around. As the psychological pain her mother is suffering from (due to the death of Elnora’s father) is brought to light, Elnora’s mother becomes loving and kind. It is a fairy tale, but a nice one.

Elnora is a dear girl. She deserves a good and loving mother. She also works hard to earn all of the thing she needs for school. She does this by collecting moths in the Limberlost forest and selling them to the Bird Woman. Elnora finds rare species and knows much about biology and insects because of it. (This part of the novel reminded me of another children’s series called The Melendy Quartet; in one of those books, Oliver shines his flashlight into the night sky and draws moths to his bedroom window for examination.) Not only does Elnora’s hobby pay for school, but when she graduates from high school, it earns her a job as a teacher of the natural sciences. This she must do because she has failed to save enough money for college, and her mother tries to help her find a particular rare species of moth, the golden emperor, that will earn her the money, but they fail spectacularly.


Elnora’s transformation in this first part of the novel, while interesting and uplifting, troubled me. I wanted to see Elnora complete her dream of attending college and become a talented violinist. However, the thrust of her success in this section seems to have been her looks and her materialism. As she makes new dresses, learns to shine and comb her hair, wears the right shoes, and packs the right sort of lunch, she becomes happy and fulfilled. While such conformity can certainly add to one’s social happiness, these material possessions aren’t really what make a person successful. And we see strains of that truth in Elnora’s generosity. Yet the novel promotes physical and material transformation as the most pertinent and interesting. I disagree, and I argue that intellectual and spiritual transformation, which Elnora certainly exhibits, are more important. However, the book focuses little on these attributes.

The narrative then skips ahead to Elnora’s graduation and disappointment at not having enough money for college. As she stays home that summer to collect more moths, a fascinating and educational aspect of the book for me, she meets a young man visiting from Chicago in order to recover from illness. He grows stronger and begins helping Elnora with her moth collecting. However, he’s engaged to marry somebody else, and Elnora keeps her romantic feelings in check.

The final conflicts and resolution of the novel focus on this love triangle, with Elnora eventually triumphing. She does so in the most virtuous, straightforward, and moral way, making sure that Phillip is over his fiancée and that he stopped loving her because of her spoiled and selfish nature and her mistreatment of him. Elnora does not interfere and accept Phillip’s exclamations of love and proposal of marriage until she is sure he is free.

This young adult tale has three interesting aspects. First, the educational one, in which we see how important education is to the “country girl” Elnora and how well she does in that environment. It is a fable of the country girl becoming important and making her way in the world or the “big city.” Second, I appreciated the naturalistic aspects of this novel. There’s a case to be made that it is an environmental treatise, especially since part of Elnora’s financial trouble comes because her mother will not allow oil wells to be built on their land. However, when her mother goes through her own “extreme makeover” (wearing the right clothes, living in the right part of town, and taking care of her skin), she gives into the oil wells for money. Third, there’s a romantic aspect, one that promotes virtue and pure romance.

I liked A Girl of the Limberlost for what it is, but I was disappointed at its simple theme of money and materialism leading to happiness. From this book, readers will “learn” that in order to be happy, one must dress correctly and have material goods and the money to purchase those with. I dislike this overall message, despite the seemingly innocent and pure circumstances in which it is presented. However, I recognize that this book is a product of its time, and the author either believed in the importance of social class as a marker of virtue, or felt pressure to write a tale in a way that publishers and readers expected.

No matter the deeper meanings and somewhat shallow ideologies promoted in this book, it was an enjoyable read. It was one I tried to force-read to my daughter when she was sick, but we quickly realized it was more for young adults, rather than preteens. I’m glad to have become acquainted with this novel, and I plan to read the prequel, Freckles.


25 thoughts on “Social Class as a False Marker of Virtue: A Girl of the Limberlost

Add yours

  1. You know, I took this book a little differently. First, remember that it was written in the 1930’s, so of course the happy ending is going to be Elnora finding a man. But actually, I believe that even though Elnora makes herself over a little, the lesson in the book was for the high school city girls, who learn that she is a person to be valued and that their first reaction to her was unfair, based totally on class and the country girl/city girl theme. She may get a better hairdo and and dress (she does that after they decide to make friends with her, remember, in fact they help), but she also makes them gifts from the forest for graduation and continues to hunt for moths, so she is still different from them and keeps her individuality (especially for the time). It’s just that they have learned a lesson about their own petty value system. And what high school girl wouldn’t want to have a nice graduation outfit?

    As to Freckles, in the book Freckles, he is a poor Irish boy from Chicago who is basically a street urchin. He starts out getting a job guarding a forest near Grand Rapids, MI, which years ago was lumber country. And he falls in love with the bosses’ daughter, Angel, with apparently no hope for success. It is the story about how with courage and perseverance, even after he loses his arm, he proves himself worthy of her. Of course, the definition of success has to do with wealth (but remember, these are post-Depression times), but you can see that in Girl of the Limberlost the wealthy aren’t always the happy characters. Take that rich, spoiled girl (I forget her name, is it Edith?) who loses her boyfriend to Elnora because she has been testing her powers and because she lost her temper.

    1. Yeah, Edith’s downfall was highly satisfying, and there is that theme of Elnora being who she is, which is lovely, no matter her circumstances. It was actually written in 1909, so before the depression. I think there are some lingering Victorian values. I absolutely agree that there’s another side to what I saw, but I felt like the materialism theme was strongest and overwhelming compared to Elnora’s goodness without those things.

      1. Oh, gosh, that much earlier? I didn’t look it up, obviously. She wrote for a long time, then, because I remember reading one book by her that was written during WW II. It wasn’t one of her best, however.

      2. 1909 is right there in the Gilded Age, though, when getting rich was pretty much the preoccupation of a lot of people in the U.S. If you ever want to read a funny, satirical novel and haven’t read The Gilded Age by Mark Twain, you’ve got a treat coming.

  2. I’m glad, though, to see that people are still reading Freckles and Limberlost. And my personal favorite is Laddie, a True-Blue Story, about a farmer boy who falls in love with a rich girl and sets about to prove to her that he doesn’t have to become a lawyer to lead a good and respectable life. He can be a farmer and still be worth marrying. If anything, I think Porter’s books are sort of, not exactly anti-materialist, but certainly anti-snobbery.

    1. Yes, anti-snobbery is a good way of saying it! Maybe that everybody can “rise” but that doesn’t mean compromising standards. I’ll look into Laddie!

  3. This sounds pretty interesting. I wonder about it’s environmental ethics especially. I recently re-read some Paul Bunyan stories and was appalled that a story I remember loving involved the complete destruction of natural environments, but it was a story of a time when that was the prevailing ethic.

    1. Yeah, I think this book has much the same version of ethics. There are some really great parts about the natural world and protecting and engaging with it in productive ways, but that message fails somewhat toward the end.

  4. Emily, it will be interesting to see if your opinion changes once your read the prequel. Maybe there is context missing. Without having read either, I will need to follow your correct assessment that money and materialism do not necessarily lead to happiness and when given too much priority will have the opposite effect. BTG

    1. I wonder, too, if the prequel will change anything. I really enjoyed this one, but I’ve been trained to be critical as I read, so that’s what happened here!

  5. I don’t remember “Girl of the Limberlost” like this… but it has been over twenty years since I read it. Your review makes me want to find it and read it again! Plus, I had no idea it was a sequel, either!

  6. Porter was one of my former mother-in-law’s absolute favorite authors and I have yet to read any of her books. You’ve inspired me, however, Emily! Perhaps especially since I am reading the Green Gable series this year…for the first time. Thanks for the review!

  7. Good for you for pointing out what made this book problematic. I remember reading several books like this growing up, and I was disappointed when many of them “ended” after the female protagonist had learned “how to be pretty.”

    1. Looks just aren’t what’s important and we get so much of that message in contemporary media that its presence in an older book was disappointing. Still a fun read though.

Join the Conversation

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: